Free Newsletter
 Subscribe Now
 BR Blog

 COMPANY NEWS
Saccawu tackles racism in its sectors  Comments

Union plans industrial action at Pick n Pay
  • Ackerman says accusations are
    December 9, 2009

    By Florence de Vries


    Retail giant Pick n Pay is the fourth company to be accused of "racist practices" this year by members of the SA Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers' Union (Saccawu) who work for the companies.

    Saccawu spokesman Mike Abrahams said the union was "concerned about similar allegations" at supermarket group Shoprite, pharmacy chain Dis-Chem and leisure group Sun International.

    Abrahams said the union was still waiting to hear from officials working in these companies about its members' experiences "perceived as racist at the workplace".

    The union was planning industrial action against Pick n Pay following the group's alleged reluctance in "adequately responding to a long, drawn-out dispute with Saccawu over a range of racist practices".

    The Labour Court in Braamfontein yesterday postponed Saccawu's challenge against the interdict that Pick n Pay brought to prevent the union from taking industrial action against it. The matter will be heard today.

    Saccawu said on Monday that its complaints against Pick n Pay included inconsistency in its application of discipline, with a bias against black employees and Saccawu members.

    The union alleged that some managers were racist and Pick n Pay had failed to discipline them. There were also discrepancies in income between black and white employees occupying the same positions or doing work of similar value.

    White employees earned more, Saccawu said. It further alleged that "racial comments" against black employees had been made by Pick n Pay's chief executive Nick Badminton.

    Former Pick n Pay chairman Raymond Ackerman described Saccawu's accusations as "a slap across the face" as he had spent more than half his life fighting racism.

    "I am disgusted with this. We've tried for years to meet with Saccawu but they've chosen to take us on just before Christmas in the worst economy possible," he said, adding that Saccawu had gone against the principles of true unionism in what was "obviously a political attack".


    Pick n Pay spokeswoman Tamra Veley, who is also representing the group's chief executive, rejected the racism allegations as being factually incorrect. She said some of the allegations referred back to statements that Saccawu said were allegedly made as long as 10 years ago.

    "Saccawu will not tell us why, if these statements were in fact made, it has taken over a decade to raise it with us. We reject the allegations outright."

    In an attempt to address the concerns of Saccawu, Pick n Pay has on four separate occasions proposed that an independent commission of inquiry be conducted, which Saccawu has rejected on each occasion.

    A recent "racism dispute" led to Cosatu signing a memorandum of understanding with the management of Sun International, in which the company agreed to dismiss "racist" security staff.

    The memorandum led to two employees at Sun City being suspended and one being dismissed after a racially offensive CD was played at a function where staff were strip-searched after being accused of theft.

    Sun International's management acknowledged last week that some Sun City employees had not been treated with respect and said strong action would be taken against those responsible.

    Dis-Chem operations director Brian Epstein said the union had "just started having talks about the alleged allegations, but nothing came of it".

    Abrahams said levels of racism lingered in the sectors it organised. Saccawu is represented in the hospitality, wholesale and retail sectors with over 150 000 members nationally.

    According to Abrahams, the group is also organised within Massmart, Edcon, Woolworths, Shoprite, JD Group, Lewis, Pep, Foschini and Spar.
  • BOOKMARK THIS STORY

    Social bookmarking allows users to save and categorise a personal collection of bookmarks and share them with others. This is different to using your own browser bookmarks which are available using the menus within your web browser.

    Use the links below to share this article on the social bookmarking site of your choice.

    Read more about social bookmarking at Wikipedia - Social Bookmarking

    Showing page 1 of 1 comment pages, 6 total comments
    36 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
    I am not pro-union, but this time support the union allegations that racism exists in South African retailers with little evidence of transformation. I was a retail executive at one of the largest SA retailers. At all retailers, the overwhelming majority of management, and executive structures are white (the figures speak for themselves). The majority of store staff are black. A glass ceiling exists for talented black staff. How is it done, you may ask? The performance management processes are subjectively enforced to benefit the growth and development of white employees because the white executive structures have “more in common” with these staff members. Black staff in stores are often subject to abuse with little recourse to company disciplinary processes. After a few years, I left in frustration as many talented black staff were marginalized and eventually became frustrated, reflecting their behavior toward customers. There is also little justification for the enormous salary, share option differences between executive and store level staff (predominantly black). I am just surprised that this issue is only now coming to the fore. All races deserve equality of opportunity in SA.
    38 Weeks ago Forester wrote :
    All of these apparently racist actions reveal how the Unions actually think that their members are inferior in performance, and are therefore more sensitive to what's going on. This sense of inferiority translates into the "chip on the shoulder" attitude. Remember, good people, how fortunate you are to ahve your job, and that you should value it and not try to cause trouble at every turn. Union Members: show the Unon bosses that you can think for yourselves!
    38 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
    I believe some people have massive chips on their shoulders and are definitely not of the sort to get over it. It just shows how certain people feel the world ows them. Let me just say the world ows you nana. It is up to you to prove your worth. Stop being childish and start facing your own demons, for that shows strenght and courage!
    38 Weeks ago Terry. Cape Town, Soputh Africa. wrote :
    Racism, Racism, Racism, Racism, - from my long, lifetime observations and accurate assessments in our once sunny but now gloomy South Africa, racism is a game played by fools. It is a game fraught with foul play and violations of dignity; this by players who are normally without any common sense or any sensitivity to the feelings of others, and who live with a really bad inferiority complex; this because of laziness and lack of effort to raise himself to a level of acceptability and respect. It has absolutely nothing to do with the color of a man or woman's skin. The criteria that form the foundations that relate to the acceptance or rejection of any candidate are based on, - checked and very well- established qualifications, experience, efficiency, productivity, integrity and good timekeeping. Traits in personality, appearance and ability to work, mix and co-operate congenially with one's fellow workers and colleagues also rate highly. Only total fools would be tempted to operate outside of these norms when it comes to staff selection and employment. To sum up,- All people who judge fellow humans based only on the pigment of the skin are fools who should be ignored. They are the proverbial empty vessels that, true to character and qualifications, make the most noise!!!
    38 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
    I have a funny feeling that the racism allegations have to do with workers not doing their job properly, and when being reprimanded, shout "racism". Hey, if you want to be lazy, undisciplined, not adhering to company policy, not doing your job, etc, go and work for government. In the private sector, we work!
    38 Weeks ago Keletso Pekile wrote :
    Ha; ha; ha; ha! This reminds me of the Black Journalists saga earlier on. Fifteen years into so called democracy, and yet we see all these issue raising their ugly heads. Are we really free or we are just bunch of people using terminology to fool themselves? One thing that becomes clear herein - BLACKS CAN NEVER BE RACISTS. aluta!
    HAVE YOUR SAY
    Please enter your comment into the text box below.
    Note: all comments are moderated (see our moderation policy) and may take some time to display, or may not appear at all.
    If you would like to use an alias, please type it below. If you do not enter an alias you comment under a Anonymous byline.
    Type your email address below - your comment will not be accepted without it. This is required as part of our moderation guidelines, but your address will not be published or distributed.
    Lastly, to help fight spam, enter the letters in the image below as you see them.

         

    BUSINESS SERVICES
    Book a Flight
    Business Directory
    Car Insurance
    Car Insurance for Women
    Compare and Save
    House for sale
    Insurance Quote
    Life Insurance
    Life Insurance for Women
    Maps & Direction
    Medical Aid
    Mobile Business Directory
    Online Shopping
    Personal Loans
    Property Search
    Travel Specials
    UK and Euro Lottery

    MOBILE SERVICES
     Get Business Headlines & Indicators
     on your phone - dial *120*IOL*5#
     Click here to find out more (SA only)


    Sign up for IOL Faxmail


    Company News


    News


    Markets


    Technology News


    International