Free Newsletter
 Subscribe Now
 BR Blog

 NEWS
SA forced to weigh other airlift options for military  Comments
November 10, 2009

By Donwald Pressly


South Africa now faces the choice of accepting that it cannot play a regional peacekeeping role after it cancelled the order for the Airbus A400M military transport planes or it will have to look at the option of mixing different aircraft, according to Jane's Defence Weekly correspondent Helmoed-Römer Heitman.

Responding to the cancellation of the order last week by the cabinet, Heitman said that a mix could include the Hercules C-130 and C-17s. It could also include some A400Ms with a few of the C-130s and C-17s. This would be an option as the A400M was a large aircraft that could not land at all airports.

Heitman said the C-130 was an extremely capable aircraft "but it cannot by itself meet the requirement. Simply buying the same basic payload capacity would require 15 C-130Js for about R19 billion."

He noted this would be similar to the cost of the A400Ms. He disputes Defence and Military Veterans Minister Lindiwe Sisulu's cost estimate for the eight A400Ms at R30bn and Armscor chief executive Sipho Thomo's estimate of R47bn.


He noted the C-130J could not transport the large vehicles and heavier equipment, for example vehicles that can withstand road-side bombs, that would be required for future missions.

The C-130J was also not a practical means of deploying an Oryx helicopter.

"The gearbox must be taken off and that means a second aircraft (has) to fly in the gantry needed for re-assembly and 24 hours of work before the Oryx flies instead of four." Heitman argued that it was not practical to continue chartering old ex-Soviet air force transport aircrafts.

A chartered Yak-42 aircraft crashed in Turkey on its way to Afghanistan in 2003. This was a warning sign, he indicated.
BOOKMARK THIS STORY

Social bookmarking allows users to save and categorise a personal collection of bookmarks and share them with others. This is different to using your own browser bookmarks which are available using the menus within your web browser.

Use the links below to share this article on the social bookmarking site of your choice.

Read more about social bookmarking at Wikipedia - Social Bookmarking

Showing page 1 of 1 comment pages, 4 total comments
12 Weeks ago Bemused wrote :
The option of purchasing brand new Russian or Ukrainian aircraft (IL or An) never seemed to be seriously explored. The Ukraine, with Russian partners (on-off-on again) has been developing the Antonov An 70, which is flying, provides better capability, is cheaper than the A400M and they would have loved a partner like the SA aerospace industry. Their overtures were rebuffed. Yet, in a stunningly quick move, the government signed up on the A400M, despite the fact that the signs were already there at that stage that the project was not going as smooth as they wanted us to believe. The question is why, and is sanity now going to prevail?
13 Weeks ago ARCHIE_ wrote :
This happened on Guy Fawkes day. An action by cabinet brought this whole Airbus shady deal to a crashing end. Good. The money goes to the real national and, in fact, continent-wide security threat that is Eskom. Pigs will fly before the A400M, and sadly, likely also before Boeing's commercial 787.. With regards that tax black hole that SAA has unfortunately become, the (Boeing) 777-300ER is un beaucoup meilleur avion que l'A340-600 (The Boeing carries more passengers, has more floor space, more cargo, flies faster, further, has half as many engines - but more power - and uses about 20% less fuel).. Perhaps, when dealing with these multinationals - as government dealing with state enterprises - less favours for them - and less winner-takes-all. Play them against each other and take the best from each - they will give you their best. Stay away from the An-124 - the similarly sized commercial 747 is a better plane - these are very large 100-tonne payload planes. The An-124 is suited to outsized cargo - but is unreliable. Either pick the expensive Boeing C-17 Globemaster III, or go with up-to-date versions of the tried, tested, trustworthy Lockheed Martin C-130 Hercules. Most of all. Expert tender process. (Take note of the tender process for the United States Air Force tanker replacement competition - also a considerable mess.)
13 Weeks ago Anonymous wrote :
The debate is still centering on the purchase of US/NATO standard aircraft. Antonov (a leading Ukrainian Russian conglomerate) has already built the first new Antonov 70 - an aircraft comparable and even better in most aspects than the Airbus A400M. This option wasn't even considered and should be considered...especially as the unit cost is 50% less than the Airbus....this is something our "military specialists" should investigate
13 Weeks ago Pierre Hough wrote :
Accepting we cannot and should not play peacekeeping roles, we must also come to realise that we are not ready to go to war in any event. What now? Cut the Defence budget, and start all over again. Sadly, the reality must also prevails that with the competence that currently prevail in the current SANDF (and I am not including some very competent people) it's is best to start afresh, get rid of the incompetents and realise that we are extremely vulnerable as a nation. There still is huge competency - but outside of the current defence system and in civil society. If we wait any longer, that will also fade away. Perhaps that is what is being achieved ...
HAVE YOUR SAY
Please enter your comment into the text box below.
Note: all comments are moderated (see our moderation policy) and may take some time to display, or may not appear at all.
If you would like to use an alias, please type it below. If you do not enter an alias you comment under a Anonymous byline.
Type your email address below - your comment will not be accepted without it. This is required as part of our moderation guidelines, but your address will not be published or distributed.
Lastly, to help fight spam, enter the letters in the image below as you see them.

     

BUSINESS SERVICES
Awesome UK Lotto's
Business Directory
Car Insurance
Car Insurance for Women
City Guide
Insurance Quote
Life Insurance
Life Insurance for Women
Maps & Direction
Medical Aid
Meetings Africa
Mobile Business Directory
Online Shopping
Personal Loans
Play Huge Lottos
Property Search
Travel Specials

MOBILE SERVICES
 Get Business Headlines & Indicators
 on your phone - dial *120*IOL*5#
 Click here to find out more (SA only)



News


Markets


Technology News


Company News


International